Original language

English

Country
Canada
Date of text
Status
Unknown
Type of court
National - higher court
Sources
Court name
Federal Court
Seat of court
Ottawa
Reference number
2011 FC 72
Tagging
Constitutional, Evidence, Human Rights, Jurisdiction, Admissibility, Remedies, Taxation, Forests
Free tags
Legal questions
Justice(s)
Zinn, R.W.
Abstract
The applicants are three Chiefs and three self governing organizations representing off-reserve Aboriginal peoples, the Native Council of Nova Scotia, the New Brunswick Aboriginal Peoples Council and the Native Council of Prince Edward Island. The applicants seek a declaration that the decisions of Governor in Council and the Minister of Industry regarding the 2011 Census and National Household Survey are unconstitutional in that they infringe equality rights of Aboriginal people. The Federal Court found that the 2011 Census and National Household Survey did not infringe the equality rights (s. 15 of the Canadian Charter) of off-reserve Aboriginal people because no distinction was made based on aboriginality or non-residence on reserve. The Court found that in order for s. 15 to invalidate a law, the law itself must be discriminatory; a discriminatory effect is not sufficient.